Skip to content
TotalMonthly

Loans

VA vs FHA vs Conventional Loans: Which Costs Less?

Compare VA, FHA and conventional loans on down payment, mortgage insurance, upfront fees and monthly cost, with a worked example on a $400,000 home.

By Muhammad Bashir, founder of TotalMonthlyPublished · 5 min read

VA, FHA or conventional? Which costs less. Three front doors side by side, painted teal, amber and navy, with potted plants by the steps
CalculatorVA loanRun your numbers

If you qualify for all three, a VA loan is usually the cheapest of the group, and the gap is often large. If you do not qualify for VA, the choice comes down to FHA or conventional, and your credit score and down payment decide it.

Who can use each loan

  • VA: Eligible service members, veterans and some surviving spouses. You need a Certificate of Eligibility, and the home must be your primary residence.
  • FHA: Anyone who meets the credit and income requirements, for a primary residence.
  • Conventional: Anyone who qualifies, for a primary home, second home or investment property.

The basics side by side

VA FHA Conventional
Minimum down payment 0% 3.5% with a 580+ credit score As low as 3% on some programs, often 5%
Monthly mortgage insurance None Annual premium (MIP) PMI below 20% down
Upfront fee VA funding fee, 1.25% to 3.3% 1.75% upfront premium None in the usual structure
Can the insurance end? Not applicable Only with 10%+ down, after 11 years Yes, at 80% to 78% of original value
Typical credit needs Set by lenders, often flexible Lower scores can qualify Pricing rises as scores fall

The VA funding fee is a percentage of the loan: 2.15% for a first use with less than 5% down, 1.5% with 5% to 10% down, and 1.25% with 10% or more down. For a second or later use with less than 5% down it is 3.3%. Veterans with a service-connected disability rating are generally exempt. Source: the VA funding fee chart effective April 7, 2023.

A worked example: a $400,000 home

All three loans below use a 30-year term and a 6.5% rate, so the comparison isolates the fees and insurance. In real life, rates differ by loan type and lender. The figures show principal, interest and mortgage insurance only, without taxes, homeowners insurance or HOA dues, and the PMI is an estimate for a borrower with good credit.

VA, 0% down FHA, 3.5% down Conventional, 5% down
Cash for the down payment $0 $14,000 $20,000
Upfront fee (added to the loan) $8,600 (2.15%) $6,755 (1.75%) $0
Loan amount $408,600 $392,755 $380,000
Principal and interest $2,582.63 $2,482.48 $2,401.86
Monthly mortgage insurance $0 $176.92 $285.00
Principal, interest and insurance $2,582.63 $2,659.40 $2,686.86

The VA loan has the biggest balance because the funding fee is financed, yet it still has the lowest monthly payment because it carries no mortgage insurance. It also needs no down payment. The conventional loan has the smallest balance and the highest payment in this example because PMI at 5% down is expensive.

The conventional payment improves as your credit score improves and as your down payment grows. With 20% down there is no PMI at all, and the payment on the same home falls to about $2,022.62. Use the PMI calculator to see how long PMI would last on your loan.

When each one tends to win

VA tends to win when:

  • You are eligible. No down payment and no monthly mortgage insurance is hard to beat.
  • You want to keep cash for reserves, repairs or moving costs.
  • You expect to keep the loan a long time, since there is never a monthly premium to outlast.

FHA tends to win when:

  • You are not VA eligible and your credit score makes conventional PMI expensive.
  • You have a small down payment and limited savings.
  • You plan to refinance or sell within a few years, before the long-run cost of the premium builds up.

Conventional tends to win when:

  • Your credit score is good to excellent, which makes PMI cheap.
  • You can put down 10% or more, or a full 20%, which removes or shrinks PMI.
  • You want to buy a second home or an investment property.

For a closer look at the FHA and conventional tradeoff, see FHA vs conventional loans and PMI vs MIP.

Costs the table does not show

  • Closing costs apply to all three loans. VA limits some of the fees a veteran can be charged, but not every cost. See closing costs explained.
  • Appraisal standards differ. VA and FHA appraisals check that the home meets minimum property requirements, which can add repairs or delays.
  • Loan limits for FHA and conventional loans vary by county. VA limits depend on your remaining entitlement.
  • Seller negotiations can be affected. Some sellers prefer conventional offers, so ask your agent how competitive each loan type is in your market.

How to compare your own numbers

  1. Run each loan in its own calculator with the same price: the VA loan calculator, the FHA loan calculator and the mortgage calculator set to conventional.
  2. Enter a quoted rate for each loan type instead of one shared rate.
  3. Compare the full monthly payment, the cash you need to close, and the total cost over the years you expect to keep the loan.

Common questions

Is a VA loan better than an FHA loan?

For eligible borrowers, usually yes. A VA loan has no monthly mortgage insurance and does not require a down payment, while FHA charges both an upfront premium and a monthly premium. VA also charges a funding fee, but it is generally lower than the lifetime cost of FHA mortgage insurance. The exact comparison depends on your down payment and rate.

Is a VA loan better than a conventional loan?

Often, when you put less than 20% down. Conventional loans charge PMI below 20% down, while VA does not. If you can put 20% down and have strong credit, a conventional loan has no PMI and no funding fee, so the two can end up close.

Can I use a VA loan more than once?

Yes. You can use VA loan benefits again if you have entitlement remaining. The funding fee is higher for second and later uses when you put little down, 3.3% instead of 2.15% in the example above.

Which loan has the lowest down payment?

VA, at 0%. FHA starts at 3.5% with a 580+ credit score, and some conventional programs start at 3%.

Key takeaways

  • A VA loan combines no down payment with no monthly mortgage insurance, which is why it often costs the least for eligible borrowers.
  • Between FHA and conventional, credit score and down payment decide the winner.
  • Compare quoted rates, cash to close and total cost over your expected time in the home, not just the headline payment.

For education, not financial or legal advice. Rules, rates and fees change; confirm with a lender or licensed professional. See our methodology and disclaimer.

Keep reading

All guides