Loans
PMI vs MIP: Conventional and FHA Mortgage Insurance Compared
PMI and MIP both protect the lender, but they cost and end differently. See a worked comparison on a $400,000 home and how your credit score changes the answer.
By Muhammad Bashir, founder of TotalMonthlyPublished · 5 min read
PMI is the mortgage insurance on conventional loans. MIP is the mortgage insurance on FHA loans. Both protect the lender if you stop paying, and you pay for both. The difference is how much they cost and, above all, how long you pay.
The short version
- PMI has no upfront cost in the usual monthly structure, its price depends heavily on your credit score and down payment, and it can be removed when you reach about 20% equity.
- MIP has two parts: an upfront premium of 1.75% of the loan and an annual premium paid monthly. With less than 10% down it generally lasts as long as the loan.
If your credit score is strong, PMI is usually cheaper over a long stay. If your score is lower, MIP can be cheaper, at least for the first years.
How each one is priced
| PMI (conventional) | MIP (FHA) | |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Usually none | 1.75% of the base loan, normally financed |
| Monthly cost | Varies with credit score and loan-to-value | 0.50% a year at 95% loan-to-value or less, 0.55% above that (base loan up to $726,200, terms over 15 years) |
| Who sets the price | The private insurer, based on your risk | HUD, the same for every borrower in the same bracket |
| How it ends | Request removal at 80% of original value, automatic at 78% | After 11 years with 10% or more down, otherwise generally for the life of the loan |
| Affected by credit score | Strongly | No |
FHA figures: HUD Mortgagee Letter 2023-05, for loans endorsed on or after March 20, 2023. Confirm current rates with your lender.
A worked example: $400,000 home, 5% down
The loan is $380,000 over 30 years at 6.5%. FHA adds a $6,650 upfront premium to the loan and a 0.50% annual premium of $158.33 a month. Conventional PMI depends on your score, so the table shows three illustrative rates rather than quotes: 0.45% for a strong score, 0.90% for a good score, and 1.50% for a weaker score. At these inputs PMI stops after 135 months, when the balance reaches 78% of the original value.
Total mortgage insurance paid, including the FHA upfront premium:
| If you keep the loan | FHA | PMI at 0.45% | PMI at 0.90% | PMI at 1.50% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years | $16,150 | $8,550 | $17,100 | $28,500 |
| 7 years | $19,950 | $11,970 | $23,940 | $39,900 |
| 10 years | $25,650 | $17,100 | $34,200 | $57,000 |
| 30 years | $63,649 | $19,238 | $38,475 | $64,125 |
What this shows:
- Strong credit (0.45% PMI): PMI is cheaper at every point. FHA costs more from the first month because of the upfront premium and the higher monthly cost.
- Good credit (0.90% PMI): FHA costs more for the first four years or so because of the upfront premium, then comes out cheaper until about year 17. After that, PMI has ended and FHA premiums keep coming, so conventional wins if you stay the whole term.
- Weaker credit (1.50% PMI): FHA comes out cheaper after the first two years and stays cheaper for the whole term in this example, by a small margin at 30 years.
The turning point is how long you keep the loan. The longer you stay with an FHA loan and less than 10% down, the more the lifelong premium matters. Many FHA borrowers solve this by refinancing into a conventional loan once they have enough equity. That costs closing fees, so it only helps if the savings outlast them. See should you refinance?.
What changes with a larger down payment
With 10% down on the same $400,000 home, the FHA annual premium of 0.50% stops after 11 years. The conventional loan carries a lower PMI rate because the loan-to-value is lower. In the calculator’s estimate, PMI on a $360,000 loan is about $210 a month and ends after roughly 109 months, while the FHA premium is $150 a month for 132 months plus the $6,300 upfront premium.
Ten percent down helps both loans, but it helps conventional more, because PMI pricing falls quickly as loan-to-value drops.
How to compare your own loan
- Get a PMI quote from lenders based on your actual credit score and down payment. The estimate in a calculator is a midpoint, not an offer.
- Add the FHA upfront premium (1.75%) to the FHA side. It is easy to miss because it is financed.
- Compare total insurance cost over the number of years you expect to keep the loan, not just the monthly figure.
- Check the PMI calculator for how long PMI lasts at your down payment, and the FHA loan calculator for the full FHA payment.
For the wider decision between the two loans, read FHA vs conventional loans.
Common questions
Is PMI cheaper than MIP?
Often, when your credit score is good to excellent, and especially if you plan to stay in the home a long time. PMI can also be removed, while FHA MIP generally cannot with less than 10% down. With a lower credit score, PMI can cost more than MIP.
Can I remove MIP?
With less than 10% down, MIP generally lasts for the life of the loan. With 10% or more down, it ends after 11 years. Most borrowers who want to drop it refinance into a conventional loan once they have about 20% equity.
Is MIP tax deductible?
Rules for deducting mortgage insurance have changed several times and depend on your income and the tax year. Ask a tax professional rather than assuming a deduction.
Does PMI go away on its own?
Yes. You can ask your servicer to cancel it when the balance reaches 80% of the original value, and it ends automatically when the balance is scheduled to reach 78%, provided you are current on payments. See PMI explained.
Do VA loans have PMI or MIP?
No. VA loans charge a one-time funding fee instead of monthly mortgage insurance. See VA vs FHA vs conventional loans.
Key takeaways
- PMI depends on your credit and can end. MIP is priced by HUD and generally lasts for the life of the loan with less than 10% down.
- Good credit usually makes PMI cheaper over a long stay. Weaker credit can make MIP cheaper.
- Compare total insurance cost over the years you will keep the loan, including the FHA upfront premium.
For education, not financial or legal advice. Rules, rates and fees change; confirm with a lender or licensed professional. See our methodology and disclaimer.
Keep reading
All guides
Loans
VA vs FHA vs Conventional Loans: Which Costs Less?
Compare VA, FHA and conventional loans on down payment, mortgage insurance, upfront fees and monthly cost, with a worked example on a $400,000 home.

Loans
Biweekly Mortgage Payments: How Much Do They Really Save?
Paying half your mortgage every two weeks adds one extra monthly payment a year. See a worked example, how servicers apply it, and a simpler way to get the same savings.

Loans
Can You Skip a Mortgage Payment? Options If You Can't Pay
Missing a mortgage payment without an agreement brings late fees and credit damage. Learn what happens and the forbearance, deferral and modification options.

