Skip to content
TotalMonthly
Photo: Beyond My Ken · CC BY-SA 4.0

County data

Cayuga County, NY Mortgage Calculator

The median home here is worth $171,000, 60% below the New York median. Cayuga County's 2.37% property tax rate is higher than in 98% of U.S. counties. Main towns: Auburn, Weedsport and Port Byron.

Where is the home?

Cayuga County, NY

Property tax: 2.37% of value a year · Typical home value: $171,000 · Conforming loan limit: $832,750 (U.S. Census ACS median for owners with a mortgage; FHFA).

Loan type
$50k$1M$2M

20.0% down · $34,000

Loan term

Freddie Mac weekly national average, November 12, 2026: 7.11% (30-year), 6.45% (15-year). Enter your quoted rate. Rate history

Taxes, insurance and HOA

Cayuga County, NY median: 2.37%. Your bill may differ.

Cayuga County, NY: state estimate from NAIC averages. Get a quote.

Enter 0 if none.

Other costs of owning (maintenance, utilities)

1% of price a year. More for older homes.

Electric, gas, water, trash.

Internet, lawn, pest control.

Pay off sooner (optional)

Try an example

Tap one to load it.

Estimated monthly payment

$1,421/month

Loan amount: $136,000

64%is principal
& interest
  • Principal & interest$915
  • Property tax$336
  • Home insurance$170
  • HOA dues$0
Total interest
$193,357
Paid off

True monthly cost of owning

$1,883/month

  • Mortgage payment (with tax and insurance)$1,421
  • Maintenance and repairs$142
  • Utilities$250
  • Internet and other$70

Maintenance, utilities and other costs are estimates outside your loan payment. Edit them under "Other costs of owning".

Compare loan terms

Monthly payment and total interest for 15, 20 and 30 year terms at the same rate
TermMonthlyTotal interest
15 years$1,737$85,541
20 years$1,569$119,216
30 years$1,421$193,357

Same price, down payment and rate. Real rates are usually lower for shorter terms.

Loan balance over time

Year 0
First five years of the loan
YearPrincipalInterestBalance
1$1,352$9,626$134,648
2$1,452$9,527$133,196
3$1,558$9,420$131,637
4$1,673$9,306$129,964
5$1,796$9,183$128,168

Amortization schedule

YearPrincipal paidInterest paidBalanceTotal principal paid
Annual totals. The CSV is month by month.

Monthly payment

$1,421 /mo

See breakdown

Cayuga County by the numbers

Median home value

$171,000

Property tax rate

2.37%

New York: 1.64% · U.S.: 1.05%

Median income

$67,904

Conforming loan limit

$832,750

Monthly cost of the median home

Principal and interest

$920

$136,800 at 7.11%, 30 years

Property tax

$338

2.37% of $171,000 a year

Home insurance

$170

State estimate, NAIC averages

Together

$1,428

before HOA and PMI

Lenders don't set rates by county. The 7.11% here is the national weekly average; your quote depends on credit, down payment and loan type.

Open in the calculatorHow this loan pays downRefinancing? See the break-even

Mortgage recording tax in Cayuga County

New York taxes every mortgage when it's recorded. In Cayuga County the borrower pays 0.75% of the loan (Form MT-15): about $1,001 on the $136,800 loan for the median home with 20% down, due at closing. The lender pays the other 0.25% (Tax Department).

Refinancing? The new lender can take over your current mortgage and add to it (a CEMA, Tax Law §255), so the tax is due only on new money, not again on the balance. Not every lender offers it. See when a lower rate pays back the costs in the refinance calculator.

Cayuga County compared

With about 75,102 residents, Cayuga County is the 36th largest of 62 counties in New York. Its median home value is higher than in 43% of U.S. counties.

Each $100,000 of home value costs about $2,370 a year in property tax, versus $1,640 statewide. Cayuga County ranks 23rd of 62 New York counties for tax rate.

Buying the median home fits a typical budget: The 28% rule needs $53,900 a year, and the median household earns $67,904. Of 62 counties in New York, 40 have a higher median-home payment.

Counties next to Cayuga County

3 of 7 bordering counties have a lower median-home payment. Seneca County is lowest ($1,128), Tompkins County highest ($2,126).

CountyMedian homeTax ratePayment
Cayuga County (this county)$171,0002.37%$1,258
Seneca County$155,4002.25%$1,128
Oswego County$151,7002.64%$1,150
Cortland County$162,1002.70%$1,237
Jefferson County$188,2001.66%$1,273
Wayne County$170,0002.67%$1,293
Onondaga County$200,2002.59%$1,510
Tompkins County$290,9002.31%$2,126

Where Cayuga County is

Main towns: Auburn, Weedsport, Port Byron, Moravia, Union Springs, Aurora, Cayuga and Cato. 19 ZIP codes use Cayuga County's tax rate in the calculator.

13021130221302413026130331303413071130811309213111131131311713118131391314013147131561316013166

Similar home prices in New York

All New York counties

Frequently asked questions

How much is property tax in Cayuga County?

Owners with a mortgage pay a median $4,049 a year on a $171,000 home, or 2.37%. That compares with 1.64% across New York. Exemptions and reassessment change individual bills.

How much is the mortgage payment on a median home in Cayuga County?

With 20% down on $171,000 and a 30-year loan at 7.11%, principal and interest run $920 and property tax $338, so $1,258 before insurance.

What income do you need to buy a home in Cayuga County?

About $53,900 a year keeps the median home's $1,258 payment under 28% of gross income. The local median household income is $67,904.

What are mortgage rates in Cayuga County?

Lenders price by borrower, not county: Credit score, down payment, loan type and points. The national weekly average is 7.11% for a 30-year fixed loan. On the $136,800 loan for the median home, each 0.25 point adds about $23 a month.

Sources: Census ACS 2024 5-year (2020-2024) medians (owners with a mortgage), FHFA loan limits, Freddie Mac rate of November 12, 2026. Payments assume 20% down and a 30-year fixed loan. Methodology