Skip to content
TotalMonthly

Rent vs Buy Calculator

Buying isn't always better. It depends on how long you stay and what prices and investments do.
  • Free, no sign-up
  • Your inputs stay in your browser

After taxes and fees.

After 7 years

Buying is ahead by $13,556

Buying pulls ahead for good by year 6

  • Net worth if you buyEquity $170,265 after selling costs, plus savings invested$170,265
  • Net worth if you rentDown payment and closing money invested, plus monthly savings$156,709
  • Monthly cost of owning (first year)Principal, interest, tax, insurance, maintenance$2,984.33
  • Monthly rent (first year)$2,400.00
  • Home value at the end$491,950
  • Loan balance at the end$292,167
Buying minus renting, by year
YearHome valueBuy net worthRent net worthBuy ahead by
Year 1$412,000$70,462$102,820−$32,357
Year 2$424,360$85,497$113,192−$27,695
Year 3$437,091$101,131$123,074−$21,943
Year 4$450,204$117,393$132,417−$15,024
Year 5$463,710$134,315$141,173−$6,858
Year 6$477,621$151,927$149,289$2,639
Year 7$491,950$170,265$156,709$13,556

A model, not a forecast. Small changes in growth, returns or years can flip the result.

After 7 years

Buying is ahead by $13,556

Details

Assumptions

  • You pay a 30-year fixed loan with the rate shown, and the buyer pays closing costs up front.
  • Whoever spends less each month invests the difference at the return you enter. The renter also invests the down payment and closing costs.
  • Property tax, insurance and maintenance stay at their first-year dollar amounts; rent and home value grow at the rates you enter.
  • At the end the owner sells and pays the selling costs. Taxes on gains or investment returns are not modeled.

By Muhammad Bashir, founder of TotalMonthly

How the comparison works

If you buy, your wealth is the home's value minus the loan balance and selling costs, plus anything saved when owning costs less than renting. If you rent, it's the down payment and closing money invested, plus the monthly difference when renting costs less.

Buying often trails early, because of closing and selling costs and interest-heavy payments. Over a longer stay, equity and appreciation usually close the gap.

What drives the answer

How long you stay, the local rent-to-price ratio, how fast prices and rents grow, and what you'd earn investing instead. Small changes can flip the result.

Frequently asked questions

Is renting throwing money away?

No. Rent buys housing, and owning has unrecoverable costs too: interest, taxes, insurance and maintenance. Owning builds equity, but carries its own costs and risks.

How long do I need to stay to make buying worthwhile?

Often five to seven years, but it varies with prices, rates and rents. The break-even year here is for your inputs.

What about the mortgage interest deduction?

It only helps if you itemize above the standard deduction, which many households don't. This model leaves tax effects out.

Related calculators

Estimates only. TotalMonthly is not a lender or advisor; confirm figures with a licensed professional. See the methodology and disclaimer.